Turn Your Valuables Into Cash at Costa's

Sell Inherited Jewelry, Scrap Gold, Silver, Gold & Collector Coins for Top Dollar

Speak directly with our experts for a free, no-obligation offer by calling +1 (262) 360-5516

Our specialties

We Specialize in Buying & Selling Jewelry, Gold, Silver & Coins

At Costa’s Fine Jewelry & Coins, we’re your trusted local experts for turning valuables into cash or finding unique treasures.

As a family-owned business, we offer personal attention and honest appraisals you can trust.

Whether you’re looking to sell or buy, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.

Buying & Selling Inherited Jewelry

Estate pieces, heirlooms, and vintage jewelry—get a fair offer or discover something special.

Buying Scrap Gold

Broken, outdated, or unwanted gold items—receive top dollar, no matter the condition.

Buying Silver

Sterling silver jewelry, flatware, and coins—competitive rates for all your silver.

Buying Gold

From jewelry to bullion and coins, we pay premium prices for your gold.

Buying Collector Coins

Rare and collectible coins, gold and silver coins, proof sets, and more.

Turn Your Valuables Into Cash—Get a Free, No-Obligation Offer Now

Call us today at (262) 360-5516 for a free, no-obligation offer or to learn more about our inventory.

EXPERT JEWELRY

REPAIR

ENGAGEMENT RINGS & WEDDING BANDS

JEWELRY

DESIGN

GIA-GRADED LOOSE DIAMONDS

INVESTMENT-GRADE COINS AND COLLECTOR CURRENCY

Ready to sell your inherited jewelry, gold, silver, or coins?

Visit Costa's Today

Our friendly experts are here to help with honest appraisals and immediate payment.

Stop by our showroom for a free, no-obligation evaluation and see why so many trust Costa’s for top value and exceptional service.

Call us at (262) 360-5516 or use the map to get directions. We look forward to welcoming you!

CITIES WE SERVICE

  • Brookfield

  • Delafield

  • East Troy

  • Elm Grove

  • Franklin

  • Hartland

  • Menomonee Falls

  • Milwaukee

  • Brookfield

  • Delafield

  • East Troy

  • Elm Grove

  • Franklin

  • Hartland

  • Menomonee Falls

  • Milwaukee

MEN’S JEWELRY

Jewelry & Estate

Appraisals

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS SAY

Quote

Costa’s made selling my inherited jewelry simple and stress-free. The team was kind, and I felt confident I was getting a fair price.


April S.

Quote

brought in some old gold and silver pieces I no longer wanted. The appraisal was quick, and I walked out with cash the same day.


Devin T.

Quote

I sold a few rare coins and scrap gold at Costa’s. The staff explained everything clearly and made sure I got the best value for my collection.


Craig Z.

EXPERT APPRAISALS. HONEST OFFERS. IMMEDIATE PAYMENT.

Our team provides accurate, professional appraisals for inherited jewelry, scrap gold, silver, gold, and collector coins. We take the time to evaluate each item carefully, ensuring you receive a fair and honest offer every time.

Our process is simple and secure. Bring in your valuables for a complimentary evaluation. We will explain our assessment clearly and make a competitive offer on the spot. If you choose to sell, you receive immediate payment with no waiting and no hassle.

Whether you are selling family heirlooms, unwanted gold, or rare coins, you can trust Costa’s for integrity, transparency, and outstanding service.

Costa's Fine Jewelry and Coins in Waukesha offers competitive prices on fine diamonds, rare gemstones, and bullions. Family-owned, we specialize in engagement rings, GIA-certified diamonds, jewelry repair, and estate buying.

Get an Update

Don’t forget about upcoming holidays and promotions. Sign up below so never miss out.

Copyright © 2026. Powered by Raging Agency.

Follow us

Copyright © 2026. Powered by Raging Agency.

Follow us